SORRY I really love the show like a huge fan, but its either, change the voting system and get judges whos gonna be honest 100% like simon was or get cancelled and it doesn't look like their going to change anything. I loved David Cook and to me he was the ONLY WGWG I personally thought in my opinion deserved to win. This show is a joke and on finale night ryan bragged about 132 million votes? LOL hmm huge number but only about 6.1 million people viewed the show so that should say something LOL, this show is in fact a JOKE and mods your probably gonna remove this but you yourself knows its the God's truth.
And whats sad is that the talent on this show was so incredible compared to past seasons but the voters to me failed in the end, MY OPINION I watched a few episodes of Phillip this season (never have before) and thought the format “sucked” when females with some talent were voted off while PP, with his Dave Mathews (unable to hit the notes)wannabee voice, was not kicked off… probably to the lttle female tweens that kept this non-talent on. The show, and the judges, suck!! I will never watch this crap again!!! sorry thats just me and I am 100% sure I am not the only one who thinks that, I hated to admit this because I stuck up and loved the show so much but now I am accepting that the show will never be the same not like how it use to me. 
((((((
American Idol you will be missed 
PCE SMUA!!
Damian bain wrote:haha ahh but NO I don't roll like that, I'm actually honest when it comes to talent and give credit where its due, I don't judge people on their looks and declare them the winner like how the past 4 seasons were chosen
If tween girls or even us old ladies were voting based on looks Michael Johns would have won his season. As would have Casey Smokin'Hot James. And I seriously doubt Scotty (as deep and exciting as his voice is to us females) would've won, either.
I'm not sure you understand women, Damian.
Nffftshewasgone wrote:
Damian bain wrote:haha ahh but NO I don't roll like that, I'm actually honest when it comes to talent and give credit where its due, I don't judge people on their looks and declare them the winner like how the past 4 seasons were chosen
If tween girls or even us old ladies were voting based on looks Michael Johns would have won his season. As would have Casey Smokin'Hot James. And I seriously doubt Scotty (as deep and exciting as his voice is to us females) would've won, either.
I'm not sure you understand women, Damian.
I would also have to add Ace Young to that list. The show will never be perfect and the winner will never please everyone. Yes, the judges need to improve or be replaced; however, the days of mean-spirited judges are gone. I hope. Any how, I am just enjoying the show for entertainment and talent!
