Season 12 General Discussion

[Bookworm0963]

All the girls clearly have more talent than the guys this season, but I think Janelle maybe be the first girl gone.  The other four are giving her a run for her money. I actually would've chosen Aubrey in the Top 10 over her.

[syblcat]

Well I think this is going to be one of the most interesting events this season.

My guess, just based on how they came in this week is Amber. I personally think it ought to be Janell if we're ranking vocals, but I think Janell will have more appeal to the voting AI fans than Amber just based on genre and personality.

Now, if you add in the effect of the save, that might change the outcome, because I think the judges would save Amber if she's the first female on the chopping block. Historically, a saved contestant survives the following week's cut. If Janell has a tough week thereafter, then she might be the first female to actually say goodbye.

[boom-shaka]

---

syblcat wrote:

My guess, just based on how they came in this week is Amber.

---

But wasn't Amber 5th and Janelle 6th this week? 

[syblcat]

---

boom-shaka wrote:

---

syblcat wrote:

My guess, just based on how they came in this week is Amber.

---

But wasn't Amber 5th and Janelle 6th this week? 

---

Yeah, I think so, but based on the judges' comments, Amber should have been second or third at worst.

[boom-shaka]

---

syblcat wrote:

Yeah, I think so, but based on the judges' comments, Amber should have been second or third at worst.

---

Maybe.  At any rate, it's good evidence that the judges don't have all that much influence after all. 

[mojo2315]

@Syblcat

But Amber came in at 5th which is a good place, in a top 10. I will say Janelle based on media outlets, other social sites and the ranking last week

[mojo2315]

boom-shaka wrote:
syblcat wrote:
My guess, just based on how they came in this week is Amber.
But wasn't Amber 5th and Janelle 6th this week?
Yeah, I think so, but based on the judges' comments, Amber should have been second or third at worst.
________________________________________________________

But wasn't the Judges comment actually more favorable then most girls except Candice.... This not opinion If you go back and watch the video they actually have standing 'O' (I don't understand why people hate this more than likely because its not their favorite receiving them) and told her it was the best(I disagree that go to Kree and Candice)....

[aharris33]

Well you can't really go off the first vote. I think performances play a big part of the first few weeks of live voting then a base starts to build. 

If you look at twitter followers, Angie is in the lead with Candace right on her heels, then Kree than Janelle and then Amber. 

Of course that doesn't mean a whole lot. Nothing really does in the grand scheme of things. Those with the most steam in the beginning tend to run out of steam by the end.

I predict Amber will be the first girl to go. 

[syblcat]

---

mojo2315 wrote:
@Syblcat

But Amber came in at 5th which is a good place, in a top 10. I will say Janelle based on media outlets, other social sites and the ranking last week

---

Well we shall see. In my admittedly subjective view, country singers often do better than their reviews with voters.

[mojo2315]

Can't count twitter followers all the time because I don't even follow Kree..... I think its best if you judge twitter is to read @s to American idol or their hashtag...... Which show alot of support for the current top 4 girls Kree Candice Angie and Amber.... Also Facebook post on American Idol fan page support this too...

Which still don't say alot? Many have been voicing their gripe about Janelle making it over Racheal, now add Aubrey as far as Social media concern. I tend to check others social outlets because its not as many members here that post as it use to be seem like a small community of regulars now.